Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clintavo's avatar

Thank you for this essay. I’m currently reading Don Quixote and this viewpoint is quite a helpful lens to consider the story through.

Walker Larson's avatar

Good analysis. Don't you think, though, that Cervantes critiques Quixote's idealism just as much as Sancho's realism? At the beginning of the novel, Quixote's idealism takes the form of a highly egocentric and even self-serving form of self-professed heroism. His vision of the past is skewed, romanticized, and over-simplified, and his vision of himself is completely lacking in humility and truth. That said, I agree with you completely that Cervantes also sees a real nobility and great-heartedness in his hero, a meaningfulness in the Christendom that's fading away, and a tragedy in the materialistic, mundane, and modern worldview of the other characters. So it's complicated, I think. A both/and, perhaps? As you said, Sancho needs Quixote's idealism and Quixote needs Sancho's realism. My reading has always come back to the theological dimension, which is to say that Quixote's vision is, ironically, too materialistic as well, in the end--his vision of what heroism and chivalry should look like leaves out the central religious dimension, which was the heart of historical chivalry at its best. I think only on his deathbed does he realize that the truest adventures are of a supernatural character, and play out precisely in the "ordinary" things of life, not in fantastical fairy tales. Or, to put it differently, the fairy tales are really about spiritual sojourning in "ordinary" life. He reads the chivalric romances too literally. He fails to see the romance of the real.

13 more comments...

Ready for more?