15 Comments
User's avatar
Clintavo's avatar

Thank you for this essay. I’m currently reading Don Quixote and this viewpoint is quite a helpful lens to consider the story through.

Sean Berube's avatar

Glad it’s good timing! I’m planning to reread DQ soon myself. Such a timeless work

Clintavo's avatar

yes, I’m playing catch up. I’ve never read a lot of the classics and have been working my way through them for the past few years. I’m about halfway through Don Quixote. I admit it’s not one of my favorites so far. In fact I took a break from it to read The Alchemist by Coelho, but I’m back into DQ now. I do understand the brilliance and the “hype” around Don Quixote, the deeper questions it raises, and can see why it’s often called the first modern novel. Perhaps I will be drawn more to it when I get further in. The Brothers Karamazov didn’t “click” for me until pretty far in but now I’ll definitely reread that one someday.

Sean Berube's avatar

It was challenging for me my first read through because the absurdity of the plot made it seem too simple. The more I studied the context, and learned about Cervantes, the more enriching I found it. I believe Yale has a great lecture series on it on Youtube as well

Robert M. Woods's avatar

My wife and I just finished Don Quixote. Your essay is fantastic. Thank you for your deep and close reading of this neglected masterpiece.

Sean Berube's avatar

Thank you sir! I’m glad you found it helpful 🙏

Walker Larson's avatar

Good analysis. Don't you think, though, that Cervantes critiques Quixote's idealism just as much as Sancho's realism? At the beginning of the novel, Quixote's idealism takes the form of a highly egocentric and even self-serving form of self-professed heroism. His vision of the past is skewed, romanticized, and over-simplified, and his vision of himself is completely lacking in humility and truth. That said, I agree with you completely that Cervantes also sees a real nobility and great-heartedness in his hero, a meaningfulness in the Christendom that's fading away, and a tragedy in the materialistic, mundane, and modern worldview of the other characters. So it's complicated, I think. A both/and, perhaps? As you said, Sancho needs Quixote's idealism and Quixote needs Sancho's realism. My reading has always come back to the theological dimension, which is to say that Quixote's vision is, ironically, too materialistic as well, in the end--his vision of what heroism and chivalry should look like leaves out the central religious dimension, which was the heart of historical chivalry at its best. I think only on his deathbed does he realize that the truest adventures are of a supernatural character, and play out precisely in the "ordinary" things of life, not in fantastical fairy tales. Or, to put it differently, the fairy tales are really about spiritual sojourning in "ordinary" life. He reads the chivalric romances too literally. He fails to see the romance of the real.

Sean Berube's avatar

I agree with your analysis! Your last sentence in particular, I reckon, encapsulates the entire tragedy for Quixote - failing to see the romance in the real. I’ll simply echo your point that it’s indeed the theological domain which induces “re-enchantment,” back into the ordinary. Or, to call upon Chesterton, “The most extraordinary thing in the world is an ordinary man and an ordinary woman and their ordinary children" It’s thus, perhaps, the role of modern man to recapture that enchantment we’ve lost

Paul Fredric's avatar

Great analysis, such a wonderful book!❤️

Sean Berube's avatar

Thank you! Couldn’t agree more on DQ. Always something to discover no matter how many rereads

Wynn Crawford's avatar

I disagree. Don Quixote is largely an absurdist take on the over-romanticizing of chivalry in the books and media of Cervantes' day. A sardonic take on the chivalric romance (the Romantasy or YA-Distopian-Fiction of it's day) Cervantes uses parts one and two to critique and kill an over-wrought and deeply, derivative genre done to excess. I won't argue that there are deep, moral lessons in the novels. I won't forget to mention that I wept when Alonso Quijano renounces his madness in the end. But, ultimately the novels are a satire. Quixote and Sancho are foils but they do not foil idealism and pragmatism. They foil romanticism (madness) and ignorance (poverty). By the end the foil runs perpendicular and not parallel.

Now, I'm not a great student of Spanish Literature, so much of my understanding of the novels comes from the commentary provided by the translators. And, truthfully one can't read Don Quixote and not fall prey to some of Quijano's madness. Again, I became so engulfed in the story that I wept as Alonso recants much of his madness at the end. Yet, ultimately Don Quixote is the satire that killed a genre.

Take moral lessons from it, weep at the death of romanticism, and avoid the madness that would resurrect it.

Alexander Granath's avatar

What a beautifully crafted essay, once again, Sean.

The ending left a real mark on me, such a powerful and eloquent conclusion.

Thank you Sir!

Simon Vincent's avatar

Great article! I also write such analyses on the great and classic literature I come across and so this was inspiring. May we continue to live courageously like Don Quixote (but hopefully with less damage along the way!)

John Luongo's avatar

Great book, great perspective. I thought Cervantes, a soldier himself, sent quite a message here for those who could pick it up. Thanks for posting.

Joshua Rossi's avatar

A very concise and well written essay on the core message of this great book! I am currently reading Don Quixote myself and this essay has made its massage clearer to me!